A publishing consultant helps a writer query a experimental, fragmented work of creative nonfiction.

Open Jenny Boully's The Body: An Essay (2002), and you’ll find the pages are almost entirely blank, apart from a succession of footnotes referring to a text that apparently exists somewhere beyond the reader's reach. These notes contain recollections, digressions, literary references, and intimations of an elusive personal history. They suggest an absent narrative whose contents must be imagined from the evidence left behind. What might initially seem like an elaborate literary joke gradually becomes a haunting meditation on memory, intimacy, and the things that disappear from our lives.

Boully belongs to a group of contemporary writers who have found remarkable possibilities in the fragmentary essay. Sarah Manguso, Kate Zambreno, and others have developed books out of notebooks, aphorisms, quotations, photographs, and seemingly incidental observations. Their experiments continue a long literary tradition, extending from the notebooks of the German Romantics to the fragmentary prose of Walter Benjamin and Roland Barthes. The contemporary fragmentary essay has become particularly fertile territory for writers interested in the difficulties of reconstructing one’s experiences.

We can use Manguso's Ongoingness: The End of a Diary (2015) as an example. For twenty-five years, Manguso maintained an extraordinarily detailed diary, driven by an almost compulsive desire to preserve the events of her life. Eventually, the accumulation of recorded experience became a problem in itself. What was the relationship between the thousands of pages she had written and the life those pages were meant to preserve? Could the act of remembering become an obstacle to experiencing the present?

The resulting book is extraordinarily spare. Manguso sets aside the enormous archive she has assembled and offers a succession of brief reflections on memory, time, motherhood, and mortality. A few sentences sometimes occupy an entire page. The considerable spaces between these passages allow individual observations to linger, acquiring associations that might have been obscured by a more continuous narrative. The book's brevity seems particularly striking when one considers the tremendous quantity of material from which it emerged.

Manguso pursues this interest in compression further in 300 Arguments (2017), a collection of short, often aphoristic pieces. Individual observations stand alone, sometimes contradicting or complicating the ideas expressed elsewhere. The reader gradually becomes familiar with the recurring concerns of the book, assembling a sense of its author's intellectual and emotional life from seemingly disconnected statements. Its organization depends upon subtle relationships between passages, as well as the reader's willingness to discover those relationships.

Written over many years, Kate Zambreno's Book of Mutter (2017) assembles memories of the author's mother alongside photographs, reflections on other artists, and meditations on the difficulty of remembering the dead. Zambreno returns repeatedly to particular images and incidents, attempting to recover something that remains stubbornly inaccessible. The book preserves the awkwardness, repetition, and uncertainty of mourning. Memories surface unexpectedly, disappear, and return in altered forms.

One of the pleasures of reading Zambreno lies in observing how the fragments communicate with one another. A photograph may acquire significance only after a later passage recalls something apparently unrelated. An observation about another artist's work may illuminate an earlier recollection. The reader moves through the book much as one might examine a collection of family photographs or personal papers, following connections that emerge gradually through accumulated attention.

These writers also invite us to reconsider the practical business of composition. A conventional essay generally develops an argument or experience through a recognizable sequence of paragraphs. Fragmentary writing allows the author to work with smaller units, accumulating observations without necessarily knowing where they belong. The larger structure may emerge through revision, as the writer discovers repetitions, contrasts, and unexpected affinities among the pieces.

Of course, arranging fragments presents its own difficulties. A sequence of individually compelling passages may produce a disappointing book if their relationships remain obscure or repetitive. The author must consider where to interrupt a developing thought, how much information a reader needs, and whether an apparent digression contributes something valuable. In some manuscripts, the greatest challenge involves deciding what to leave out. Manguso's work demonstrates how a lifetime's worth of material can be reduced to a handful of carefully chosen observations.

For writers pursuing unconventional literary projects, the question of publication can introduce another set of uncertainties. A manuscript that combines memoir, poetry, criticism, and experimental prose may resist the categories through which agents and publishers ordinarily evaluate submissions. Its unusual structure might also make it difficult to summarize in a query letter or identify comparable books. A publishing consultant familiar with literary nonfiction and independent publishing can help the author identify presses, journals, and editors receptive to formal experimentation. They can offer guidance on presenting an unconventional manuscript, developing a compelling proposal or submission package, and determining whether traditional representation or direct submission to an independent press offers the more promising route. Such advice requires familiarity with the particular literary marketplace in which the book might find readers.

A publishing consultant may also help a writer distinguish between difficulties arising from the manuscript itself and those arising from its presentation. An experimental book sometimes needs further revision, while at other times its unusual qualities simply require a more carefully considered publishing strategy. The goal is to find readers and publishers capable of appreciating what the writer has accomplished.

The fragmentary essay continues to attract writers because it accommodates the unpredictable movements of thought and memory. Reading Manguso, Zambreno, or Boully, we encounter minds returning to their preoccupations, circling memories, and pursuing associations whose significance gradually becomes apparent. Their books offer a reminder that literary form remains open to invention, and that even the smallest piece of writing can acquire extraordinary power through its placement among others.

Next
Next

Africanfuturism and the Reinvention of Science Fiction